Ambuja Cements vs. UltraTech Cement: Which is a Better Buy for Long-Term Investors?

Indian cement sector is ready to grow rapidly with the boost from infrastructure construction, urbanization, and initiatives such as the “Housing for All” program. Out of the major players in this industry, Ambuja Cements and UltraTech Cement are among the strongest prospects for long-term investment. The article compares these two companies based on important financial and operational indicators to identify which one is a better investment opportunity for investors.

Financial Comparison

The financials of the two companies for Q3 FY25 give an indication of their operational prowess.

Ambuja Cements had a consolidated quarterly revenue of INR 9,329 crores, EBITDA of INR 1,712 crores, and an EBITDA margin of 18.4% and EBITDA per ton of INR 1,038. It registered a 17% year-on-year volume expansion, including 1.4 million tons from newly acquired assets such as Sanghi and Penna, which are in ramp-up stages. The company is nearly debt-free, having cash balance of INR 5,755 crores as on December 31, 2024, and net worth of INR 63,000 crores, underpinning expansive capex plans of INR 8,000 crores for FY25.

UltraTech Cement, however, posted a higher consolidated net sales of INR 16,971 crores in Q3 FY25, with a profit after tax (PAT) of INR 1,470 crores, from INR 1,777 crores in Q3 FY24. Its Q3 FY25 EBITDA was INR 3,131 crores, which is indicative of its bigger size. But UltraTech has a huge debt of nearly $2.02 billion (about Rs 16,700 crore, according to recent reports), which may prove to be a challenge for future growth. Its financials reflect strong revenue growth, but the debt is striking when compared to Ambuja’s debt-free status.

MetricAmbuja Cements (Q3 FY25)UltraTech Cement (Q3 FY25)
Revenue (INR crores)9,32916,971
EBITDA (INR crores)1,7123,131
EBITDA Margin (%)18.4Not specified, ~18.5% (est.)
PAT (INR crores)Not specified1,470
Debt PositionAlmost debt-free~Rs 16,700 crore
Cash Reserves (INR crores)5,755Not specified

Market Cap

Market capitalization is the aggregate market value of the firms, determined by the number of shares outstanding times the prevailing share price.

For Ambuja Cements, the current share price, as per recent reports, is about INR 469.25 with an estimated outstanding shares of about 2.477 billion, resulting in a market cap of about INR 116,235 crores.

UltraTech Cement, with a price of INR 10,340.80 and 288,192,628 outstanding shares, has a market capitalization of around INR 298,000 crores.

This large gap highlights UltraTech’s greater size, but Ambuja’s lower valuation ratios (explained later) indicate possible undervaluation.

Order Book

In the cement sector, “order book” is not a usual metric since cement is generally sold in the form of distributors or direct sales and not long-term contracts. No such recent reports of companies, such as earnings call transcripts and public filings, state an order book explicitly.

Volume growth and sales outlook reflect future demand instead.

Ambuja delivered 17% year-on-year volume growth in Q3 FY25, while UltraTech registered a 10% year-on-year volume growth in Q3 FY25, indicating both enjoy good demand, though individual order books are not publicly outlined.

Growth Strategy

Both players are going for aggressive growth plans, wherein they are using a mix of organic as well as inorganic expansions.

Ambuja Cements is planning to increase its cement capacity to 140 MTPA by FY28, with considerable inroads through acquisitions such as Orient Cement (to add capacity to 104 MTPA by Q4 FY25) and past acquisitions in Sanghi, Penna, Asian, and Tuticorin.

Its plan involves cost leadership, with a target of reducing costs by INR 530 per ton to INR 3,650-3,700 per ton by FY28 through renewable energy investments (1,000 MW, of which 200 MW have been commissioned in Q3 FY25) and logistics efficiencies. Its growth strategy in the market is premium products and dealer expansion, with blended cement shares of 82% and premium product sales of 26%.

UltraTech Cement’s growth plan is more aggressive, with a goal of 199.6 MTPA in FY27 and the aspiration to be the global leader in cement production with 200 MTPA. It has also sought inorganic growth through acquisitions, including a 55.49% stake in India Cements and an 8.69% stake in Star Cement, expanding its presence in the southern and eastern markets.

Organic growth involves commissioning new capacities, with the plan to increase 15-17 million tons in FY25, and operating efficiencies to sustain cost leadership. Its global reach in UAE, Bahrain, and Sri Lanka also helps in supporting growth.

AspectAmbuja CementsUltraTech Cement
Capacity Target140 MTPA by FY28200 MTPA by FY27
Key AcquisitionsOrient, Sanghi, Penna, Asian, TuticorinIndia Cements, Star Cement
Cost StrategyReduce to INR 3,650/ton by FY28Focus on operational efficiencies
SustainabilityNet zero by 2050, 60% green power by FY28Emphasis on low-carbon cement, RMC growth

Future Outlook

Both of the firms enjoy promising futures due to India’s boom in housing and infrastructure.

Ambuja Cements will benefit strongly from government initiatives for infrastructure, with anticipated cement demand growth at 4-5% in FY25, while cost-saving measures and plans to add capacity are seen pointing towards outperformance. The analysts report scope for earnings growth on stabilizing the assets that it acquired and making the switch to higher margin segments.

UltraTech Cement‘s size, while positive, with expected growth of earnings by 25.2% and revenues by 12.3% a year in line with the recent projections supported by its world’s third-largest and large network of RMC. But the company’s leverage will be limiting, if it gets high by rise in the rate of interest.

Challenges

Ambuja Cements has challenges in the integration of newly acquired assets, handling cost cuts in the face of fluctuating raw material prices, and competition in a saturated market. Environmental laws and transportation costs are other challenges, although its debt-free nature reduces the risk of financial stress.

UltraTech Cement is also battling environmental laws, the effects of climate change (e.g., cyclones impacting operations), and high debt (Rs 16,700 crore), which may burden cash flows during expansion. Competition is stiff, especially with Ambuja’s aggressive forays, and supply chain disruptions are a risk, but its greater size gives it resilience.

Valuation and Investment Verdict

Valuation ratios are essential for making long-term investment choices.

Ambuja Cements is trading at around 34.63 P/E (share price INR 469.25, TTM EPS 13.55), indicating it is relatively undervalued in relation to UltraTech Cement’s P/E of 45.75 (share price INR 10,340.80, TTM EPS 226.00).

Market cap to sales ratios are also comparable, standing at 4.89 for Ambuja (market cap INR 116,235 crores, sales TTM INR 23,788.68 crores) and 4.93 for UltraTech (market cap INR 298,000 crores, sales TTM INR 60,445.55 crores). Nevertheless, Ambuja’s debt-free position (compared to UltraTech’s Rs 16,700 crore of debt) and lower P/E ratio suggest that it is more value-for-money and financially stable for long-term growth.

Both firms distribute dividends, with Ambuja declaring a 100% final dividend in June 2024 and UltraTech distributing Rs 70 per share in July 2024, but long-term investors are concerned with growth and balance sheet strength.

Metric/AspectAmbuja CementsUltraTech Cement
P/E Ratio34.63 (Share Price: INR 469.25, EPS TTM: INR 13.55)45.75 (Share Price: INR 11,544.85, EPS TTM: ~INR 252.25)
Market Cap (INR crores)116,235333,300
Sales TTM (INR crores)~8,415.31 (annualized)16,971 (annualized)
Market Cap to Sales Ratio13.81 (Market Cap: INR 116,235 crores / Sales TTM: INR 8,415.31 crores)19.64 (Market Cap: INR 333,300 crores / Sales TTM: INR 16,971 crores)
Debt PositionDebt-free (Cash Reserves: INR 5,755 crores as of Dec 31, 2024)~INR 16,700 crore
Dividend100% final dividend announced in June 2024 (INR 2 per share)INR 70 per share paid in July 2024
Valuation InsightLower P/E ratio suggests relatively cheaper valuationHigher P/E ratio indicates a premium valuation
Financial StabilityDebt-free status enhances stability for long-term growthSignificant debt could strain cash flows, posing risks
Investment AppealBetter value with potential upside due to lower valuation and recent acquisitionsLarger scale but higher financial risk due to debt burden
Long-Term VerdictLikely a better long-term investment due to stability and growth potentialStrong growth potential but tempered by higher debt and valuation

With Ambuja’s lower valuation, debt-free status, and recent acquisitions adding market share, it appears to be a more attractive long-term investment, with potential upside with less financial risk than UltraTech’s greater size but higher debt load.

Conclusion

Studies indicate Ambuja Cements as a better long-term bet based on its lower P/E ratio, debt-free nature, and robust growth strategies despite UltraTech’s bigger size and aggressive goals. Those who seek stability and value would favor Ambuja, while investors who are at ease with the risks from debt may look to UltraTech for growth. The selection is a matter of personal risk tolerance, but Ambuja’s financials make a great case for long-term holding.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment